Doubting the Devout

The Ultra-Orthodox in the Jewish American Imagination

Nora Rubel

Columbia University Press

Doubting the Devout

Google Preview

Pub Date: December 2009

ISBN: 9780231141871

224 Pages

Format: Paperback

List Price: $28.00£21.00

Pub Date: December 2009

ISBN: 9780231141864

224 Pages

Format: Hardcover

List Price: $85.00£63.00

Pub Date: December 2009

ISBN: 9780231512589

224 Pages

Format: E-book

List Price: $27.99£21.00

Doubting the Devout

The Ultra-Orthodox in the Jewish American Imagination

Nora Rubel

Columbia University Press

Before 1985, depictions of ultra-Orthodox Jews in popular American culture were rare, and if they did appear, in films such as Fiddler on the Roof or within the novels of Chaim Potok, they evoked a nostalgic vision of Old World tradition. Yet the ordination of women into positions of religious leadership and other controversial issues have sparked an increasingly visible and voluble culture war between America's ultra-Orthodox and non-Orthodox Jews, one that has found a particularly creative voice in literature, media, and film.

Unpacking the work of Allegra Goodman, Tova Mirvis, Pearl Abraham, Erich Segal, Anne Roiphe, and others, as well as television shows and films such as A Price Above Rubies, Nora L. Rubel investigates the choices non-haredi Jews have made as they represent the character and characters of ultra-Orthodox Jews. In these artistic and aesthetic acts, Rubel recasts the war over gender and family and the anxieties over acculturation, Americanization, and continuity. More than just a study of Jewishness and Jewish self-consciousness, Doubting the Devout will speak to any reader who has struggled to balance religion, family, and culture.

Doubting the Devout analyzes the representation of the Ultra-Orthodox (haredim) in popular Jewish American literary narratives, arguing that these narratives provide insight into the deep anxiety many in the mainstream Jewish community experience in relationship to the haredim. The book's great strength lies in its close reading of texts and the originality and boldness of the argument. Nora L. Rubel makes a significant contribution to the study of contemporary American Judaism.

Rebecca T. Alpert, Temple University

Provocative, disturbing, and deeply insightful, Doubting the Devout explores the anxiety over ultra-Orthodoxy in American Jewish life today. Penetrating into the writings that few before her have had the courage to scrutinize, Rubel exposes deep-seated fears that modern Jews—and those who read them—alternatively nourish, vanquish, or repress.

Jonathan D. Sarna, Brandeis University, and author of American Judaism: A History

Doubting the Devout reveals a fascinating—and persistent—phenomenon in American culture. Haredi Orthodox Jews, for decades relegated to obscurity by more liberal coreligionists who saw them as a reactionary link to European poverty, ignorance, and pariah status, have emerged as a delectable subject in American and Israeli novels, films, and popular culture. Rubel insightfully sketches several patterns in the artistic portrayal of ultra Orthodox Jews and links those portrayals to their social historical contexts. Haredim are sometimes portrayed as authentic in their countercultural rejection of Western materialistic success. More often, Rubel shows, Haredi men are depicted as hypocritical, manipulative chauvinists, exploiting the patriarchal power granted them by rabbinic law for their own purposes and kidnapping the system (and sometimes people). In contrast, Haredi women often play sympathetic roles, beginning as oppressed victims but frequently throwing off socioreligious shackles with heroic creativity. The pervasive fear of frumkeit (religiosity) may surprise some, as the emotionalism Rubel finds transcends mere arguments 'between liberalism and traditional societal formations,' articulated not only by 'secularists who are afraid that the ultra-Orthodox are stealing their kids,' but by traditionalists who worry, 'even if your kitchen is kosher, it might not be kosher enough for your own children.'

Sylvia Barack Fishman, Brandeis University

A lucid, well-written, and clearly argued book,

Wendy Zierler, H-Judaic

Smart and perceptive book

Jewish Book World

Even if you've read none of the books Rubel discusses, hers is a worthwhile reflection on a major cultural divide in contemporary American judaism.

Rachel Gordan, Lillith
Introduction: A Family Feud
1. Orthodoxy and Nostalgia in the American Jewish Imagination
2. Rebbes' Daughters: The New Chosen
3. The New Jewish Gothic
4. Muggers in Black Coats
Conclusion: They Are Us in Other Clothes
Notes
Bibliography
Index

About the Author

Nora L. Rubel is assistant professor of religion and classics at the University of Rochester and teaches courses on American Judaism, religion and ethnicity, and religion in relation to American foodways.