Facing Death in Cambodia
Columbia University Press
Facing Death in Cambodia
Columbia University Press
The Khmer Rouge regime took control of Cambodia by force of arms, then committed the most brazen crimes since the Third Reich: at least 1.5 million people murdered between 1975 and 1979. Yet no individuals were ever tried or punished. This book is the story of Peter Maguire's effort to learn how Cambodia's "culture of impunity" developed, why it persists, and the failures of the "international community" to confront the Cambodian genocide. Written from a personal and historical perspective, Facing Death in Cambodia recounts Maguire's growing anguish over the gap between theories of universal justice and political realities.
Maguire documents the atrocities and the aftermath through personal interviews with victims and perpetrators, discussions with international and NGO officials, journalistic accounts, and government sources gathered during a ten-year odyssey in search of answers. The book includes a selection of haunting pictures from among the thousands taken at the now infamous Tuol Sleng prison (also referred to as S-21), through which at least 14,000 men, women, and children passed—and from which fewer than a dozen emerged alive.
What he discovered raises troubling questions: Was the Cambodian genocide a preview of the genocidal civil wars that would follow in the wake of the Cold War? Is international justice an attainable idea or a fiction superimposed over an unbearably dark reality? Did issues of political expediency allow Cambodian leaders to escape prosecution?The Khmer Rouge violated the Nuremberg Principles, the United Nations Charter, the laws of war, and the UN Genocide Convention. Yet in the decade after the regime's collapse, the perpetrators were rescued and rehabilitated-even rewarded-by China, Thailand, the United States, and the UN. According to Peter Maguire, Cambodia holds the key to understanding why recent UN interventions throughout the world have failed to prevent atrocities and to enforce treaties.
Peter Maguire has taken an honest look at Cambodian society. He has no agenda other than to make us examine ourselves. Maguire does not cry with us over our past; instead, what he shows us could help us move beyond being mere survivors and take a larger part in our own futures.Youk Chhang, Director, Documentation Center of Cambodia
Shattering. You think you know what happened in Cambodia under the Khmer Rouge—the broad facts, at least. But genocide has, always, an all-important context, which includes a fateful run-up and a massively complex aftermath, and in Peter Maguire's scrupulous account it is the cynicism of nearly every main player in Cambodia's national nightmare that most stunned me. The pathological cruelty of Pol Pot's regime is also fully captured, to be sure, through survivor interviews and the famous, utterly eerie photographs from Tuol Sleng prison. This is not history as culled from libraries. It is history as personal quest, with Maguire chasing his story wherever it takes him--to Vietnam, to East Germany—and making no bones about his desire to undo the final insult of impunity with unblinking accountability.William Finnegan, author of Cold New World: Growing Up in a Harder Country
Peter Maguire takes us into a dark period of world history, when a blinkered Utopian regime presided over the deaths of nearly two million of its own people. In this adventurous, thoughtful study, he draws us inexorably into the heat, squalor and magnetism of Cambodia as he confronts such troubling issues as trauma, genocide and the remote possibility of justice.David Chandler, author of Voices from S-21: Terror and History in Pol Pot's Secret Prison
Intrepid and unfettered, Peter Maguire goes where most fear to tread, into the innards of Cambodia's killing machine, to report the true—and largely overlooked—story of what happened to a country ripped asunder between US and international interests and one of the worst genocides of the 20th century. The result, quite apart from the highly readable adventure of Maguire's own journey, is righteous rage: a stinging indictment of not only the murderous Khmer Rouge, but the machinations of the United Nations and so-called 'international community'. This is a book of its time, about the zeitgeist, with resonance everywhere in a troubled world, far beyond the Cambodia Maguire knows better than any other.Ed Vulliamy, Facing Death in Cambodia
Maguire's interviews...are fascinating in their treatment of death and accountability...This is a gripping and well-written account.Library Journal
Maguire is able to put a bit of a human face on all these events.the complete review
Places in context the UN's efforts this year to establish an international tribunal on the Cambodian tragedy.Booklist
Concise, impassioned and at all times aware of the 'hallowness' of his words when compared to the survirors' own experiences, Maguire leaves readers mute.Ian Neubauer, The Cambodia Daily
Maguire's book is deftly written...The book is a sober, clear-eyed look at the questions surrounding the probable tribunal.Steve Hirsch, Phnom Penh Post
Facing Death in Cambodia is a scholarly, yet personal narrative of his own research.John Ryle, Financial Times
Maguire succeeds in illuminating the mindset of victims and perpetrators alike.D. Gordon Longmuir, Pacific Affairs
2. "Do not kill any living creature, with the exception of the enemy."
3. "The Angkar is more important to me than my father and mother."
4. "The weapon of the mouth"
5. "Only the third person knows."
6. "I am excellent survivor."
7. "Am I a savage person?"
8. "She is nice girl, but she is sick."
9. "I am no longer HIV positive."
10. "I am not dead. I am alive."
Conclusion: War Crimes Trials as a Welcome Distraction
- Read Peter Maguire’s New York Times op-ed about the Cambodian war crimes trials (July 28, 2010).
- Read Peter Maguire's New York Times op-ed Cambodia and the Pitfalls of Political Justice.